The Charlotte Gore Blog

Free Trade and Free Minds. Politics for Reasonable People. Independent Political Blogging. Top 20 Blog. Libertarianism. Laser Kitties.

If In Doubt, Simplest Argument Wins…

July 9th, 2009 at 9:22 am

Why Labour's going to lose the 'We're not cutting public spending, honest' row.

Listening to the radio yesterday I heard another minister try to explain how the Government isn’t planning to cut public spending. The argument, which goes something like this: “Because of the recession we’ve brought forward Capital investment intended for 2011 to 2008 which means that we’re still increasing investment by the same amount overall”

Everyone else’s argument is “They’re cutting investment by 10%! It’s right there in their figures!”

Who’s going to win? If in doubt, the simplest argument is usually the one that convinces the most people – this doesn’t bode well for Labour. The complexity of their argument looks far more like they’re doing little more than spreading a bit of  fear, uncertainty and doubt about what the opposition is saying – knowing full well that only a tiny minority are going to look at the actual Budget report then do the maths themselves.

It’s worth remembering Labour has form on this sort of thing – the 10p tax removal turned out to hurt rather a lot of people, a fact that Brown refused to accept for month. In that case their argument was, again, a complex explanation of benefits and tax credits whereas the opposition said, “these people will be worse off by X.” The simplest argument won there, too.

Has this post inspired your inner pedant? Try Pedants' Corner.

Hello you. I'm a semi-professional writer and this is my blog about politics and pop culture.

There's a Twitter feed as well.

You can email, too.

More from the Blog

Lib Dems: Blowing it here.

There's no referendum the Lib Dems could support that would win.

Magic and Kittens Socialism

In which I write stuff that people who already agree with me will agree with, and those that disagree will disagree.

The Revolution Will Be Commentated

You wanna know what I think?

Mortality

Need to get this out of my system.

The Big Society Bank Experiment

Don't worry. No-one gets the Big Society.

Sort Of Best Of

A hand picked selection of interesting content

Archives

For the truly committed